Centennial Lodge surrendered its Charter in 1889 but had it reinstated on May 10, 1893 when it was given dispensation to move its meeting place to Cheltenham, Maryland. Meetings were held there until 1897, when the Lodge moved into the old Bowie Mansion on Main St. in Upper Marlboro, MD. Finally, the building was purchased in 1908. It remained the home of the Lodge until it was destroyed by fire on November 14, 1964.
A new lodge building was built on Croom Station Road, just outside of Upper Marlboro, Maryland, and was dedicated on September 29, 1967 by Grand Master W. Norman Penn. Since that time the building has been enhanced and beautified and remains the home of Centennial Lodge No. 174.